Article Comment 

Super Bowl picks: From green gumbo to 'meat candy,' a few of your neighbors share game day favorites


Paulette Garton of Columbus prepares to make a hot pot of green gumbo, a family favorite for cold days and gridiron extravaganzas. Find this and other Super Bowl pick ideas in today’s food pages.

Paulette Garton of Columbus prepares to make a hot pot of green gumbo, a family favorite for cold days and gridiron extravaganzas. Find this and other Super Bowl pick ideas in today’s food pages. Photo by: Luisa Porter/Dispatch Staff


Jan Swoope



With only four days to go until Super Bowl XLVIII, football fans are making final picks -- for game day eats, that is. In Paulette and Jimmy Garton's Columbus home, the choice is often green gumbo, a hearty dish starring turnip greens. Paulette got the recipe from her mother, who lives on the Gulf Coast. Her parent got it from a Louisianian, Paulette said, which makes sense: Green gumbo -- or gumbo z'herbes -- is a Lenten tradition in the Bayou State. It can be made with smoked sausage or ham hock. Or leave the meat out and make it vegetarian. But not in the Garton's kitchen, please. Paulette's recipe calls for a pound of smoked sausage, along with bacon, potato, onion, beef broth and white beans with jalapenos. And turnips. 


"I wasn't a turnip eater growing up," Paulette admitted. It took Norfleet Reichle to make a believer out of her. "He had a huge cauldron, and he cooked up greens out in the Prairie by the gallons, at Fleets Eats," she said, referring to the iconic eatery, now long gone, where Reichle grew most of his own greens and served them up homestyle. "I learned to love them; his were just delicious."  


Her green gumbo recipe is now a family staple, one that hits the spot for Jimmy after a cold day out hunting. One all three of the couple's children, now grown and living away, have called home for. 


"The potato, when you grate it up, is really what makes it a gumbo," said the cook, who kicks her dish up a notch by adding extra jalapenos, a personal preference. The gumbo is even better when the flavors marry after sitting for a day or so, she added. 


Paulette's comfort in the kitchen isn't an accident. She grew up with eight siblings and learned more than a few things from her mother. 


"She had to cook for nine children; she was so organized she would make a menu for two weeks and post it on a bulletin board." 


Paulette did, however, eventually have to adjust her concept of quantities. "It was funny, because when I first got married, I cooked huge pots of things that would just sit in the refrigerator because they were so much," she chuckled. "I finally realized there were two of us, and there had been 11."  




More food picks 


A call out on Facebook produced other suggestions for game day food. Carolyn Pope of Columbus sent a recipe for glazed crackers. Former Columbian Carol Mabry Thorn passed on instructions for hot artichoke dip. Dispatch reporter Sarah Fowler shared her recipe for white rotel dip, which the newsroom can wholeheartedly vouch for. Likewise for Dispatch Advertising Director Beth Proffitt's onion souffle dip. 


Cookies, Etc. baker extraordinaire Diane Earwood of Columbus posted a simple idea she came across for string cheese appetizers: Chop string cheese into bite-sized pieces, freeze them in a ziplock freezer bag, then dip frozen bites in milk and bread crumbs. Bake at 425 F for eight to 10 minutes, and serve them up with marinara sauce. 


Jim Beaty at Backstage Music in Starkville prefers "meat candy." "Cocktail wieners wrapped in bacon. Bake until you think it's done, then roll in brown sugar. Winner!" 


Jan Ballard, Columbus Municipal School District School Board clerk, likes a big pot of homemade chili with sharp cheddar cheese sprinkled on top, served with cornbread.  


Former Columbian Bill Young, living now in Tuscaloosa, Ala., had an adventure to relive about inadvertently ingesting cat food, but that's a story for another day. 


A couple of people checked in from far afield. Former Columbian Mike Carroll is a professor with Universidad Salazar in Chiapas, in southern Mexico. He and his grandson watch the Super Bowl together, fortified by nachos in Velveeta cheese with chilies in it. 


And John Janssens sent greetings from Victoria, Australia. John married a Columbus girl, Tina Reid, long ago. John's suggestion for a game day spread consists of beef burgers, lamb chops and sausages, with bread and salad, beer and wine. "That's an outdoors meal," said John, "but that includes the flies." (The Aussie salute, remember, is waving one's hand in front of the face at regular intervals to shoo away Australia's infamous bush flies.) 


No flies expected in Mississippi, thankfully, when the Denver Broncos and Seattle Seahawks kick off on the Fox network at 5:30 p.m. Central Time Sunday. Enjoy the day, eat well -- and Go, Broncos. 








4-5 strips bacon, chopped 


1 onion, chopped 


2 cans beef broth 


2 cans turnips with roots 


2 cans white beans with jalapenos 


1 pound smoked sausage, cut into bite-sized pieces 


1 potato, grated 




  • Saute onion in the chopped bacon. Cook until bacon is cooked. 


  • Combine remainder of ingredients in a large pot and add bacon and onion to it. Cook until the potato is cooked (that thickens it like gumbo), usually about 30 minutes.  


    This can also be put in a crock pot and cooked several hours on a low heat. Serve with cornbread or French bread. A hearty meal for a cold night. 


  • It freezes well and tastes better as leftovers. If you cannot find the white beans with jalapenos (Trappey's), just add two cans of white beans, and jalapenos to taste. 


    (Source: Paulette Bernheim Garton, Columbus) 








    1/2 cup salted butter 


    1/2 cup unsalted butter 


    1/2 cup sugar 


    1 teaspoon vanilla extract 


    1 cup chopped pecans 


    2 sleeves Ritz Crackers 




  • Preheat oven to 325 F. Combine butters and sugar over medium heat. Bring to a boil, then boil and stir for three minutes. Add vanilla extract and chopped pecans. 


  • Arrange crackers on two jelly roll pans lined with parchment paper (saves on cleanup!). Bake eight minutes. 


  • Remove from oven and allow to cool briefly. Remove crackers with a spatula. These are yummy! 


    (Source: Carolyn Wood Pope, Columbus) 








    1 cup sour cream 


    1 cup mayonnaise 


    1 cup Parmesan cheese 


    1 small onion, minced 


    1 can artichoke hearts 




  • Drain the artichoke hearts and cut into pieces. 


  • Mix all ingredients together and bake in small casserole dish at 350 F for 30 minutes. Serve with crackers (Triskets are great with it).  


    (Source: Carol Mabry Thorn, formerly of Columbus, now living in Deatsville, Ala.) 








    1 package sausage  


    1 can Rotel (mild or hot, depending on preference) 


    2 packages Philadelphia cream cheese 


    Dash of red pepper flakes 




  • Brown sausage in skillet, adding a dash of red pepper flakes.  


  • Drain sausage and put in crock pot; add the can of Rotel (do not drain).  


  • Cut cream cheese in blocks and add to crock pot (cutting helps it melt and blend faster). 


  • Stir mixture and place crock pot on medium heat. Stir occasionally; cream cheese can quickly burn. Dip is ready to serve when it is creamy and smooth. Serve with Fritos or tortilla chips.  


    (Source: Sarah Fowler, Columbus) 








    6 8-ounce blocks cream cheese 


    1 cup mayonnaise 


    1 16-ounce container Parmesan cheese 


    Cayenne pepper, to taste (about 1 teaspoon) 


    2 large yellow onions, chopped 




  • Bake at 350 F until brown on top. Serve with Fritos. 


    (Source: Beth Proffitt, Columbus)


  • Jan Swoope is the Lifestyles Editor for The Commercial Dispatch.


    printer friendly version | back to top






    Follow Us:

    Follow Us on Facebook

    Follow Us on Twitter

    Follow Us via Email