February 1, 2011 10:21:00 AM
What''s an echo chamber? Literally, it is an enclosed, hollow space allowing our own words to bounce back to us.
Figuratively, the term has applied to most any group that surrounds itself with others that have like-minded opinions. They lock their own narrow viewpoints in, and keep others locked out.
We need fewer echo chambers, not more of them.
Perhaps we''re being cynical, but Lowndes Supervisor Leroy Brooks'' "African-American Leadership Summit," planned for Feb. 5, has all the trappings of an echo chamber. Brooks himself is a polarizing figure, with his own following. And that his "summit" is just for the black community, is exclusionary by design.
"I hoped to bring leaders together in the community and establish a dialogue," Brooks told The Dispatch last week. "There are some problems that are unique to the black community."
We wonder what these problems are -- the ones that black people have but others do not. Negative impacts from crime or the sour economy? The need to better educate our kids? The high cost, or lack of, health care? Poor infrastructure?
Those affect all of us, no matter our race.
Brooks bills the meeting as one of several Black History Month events he says he''s planning. Unfortunately, Brooks'' event epitomizes our collective failure to accept one sad reality -- that our community is desegregated, but it isn''t integrated.
What''s the difference? Desegregation could be described as a court-ordered mandate, such as desegregating a school system. However, our local schools aren''t integrated -- far from it. We divide ourselves, whether it''s by geography or with our checkbooks. Schools are only one example.
Brooks'' meeting is ostensibly open to both white and black leaders, but we have a good idea how many whites will show up.
Of course, we support more black leadership and more ownership of the future of Columbus and Lowndes County by the black community. This, however, can''t be advanced through a meeting like the one Brooks is planning. It can be advanced by black and white leaders coming together, finding common ground, and working toward common goals.
This (and every) month, let''s celebrate the contributions of blacks in this area, past and present. But let''s also come to terms with the fact that we''re more alike than we are different. Let''s find more ways to join together, not separate ourselves.
ckirby commented at 2/3/2011 12:42:00 PM:
As for this summit, coming off the interview with cult leader Louis Farrakhan, and considering that the people who are promoting this meeting are well known for their same lack of familiarity with truth and honesty, I don't see how anyone not connected to these promoters can expect anything positive to come from it. Given Mr. Brooks' and Mr. Karriem's involvement, I would expect much talk about Harry, Frank and John, plantations and division of power and much race baiting and hate mongering. No different than I would expect if the local chapter of the klan were putting on a summit after an interview with Edgar Ray Killen.
june commented at 2/12/2011 10:44:00 AM:
It is disheartening and utterly pathetic that a reputable news publication would call a gathering of black people an echo chamber and then define an echo chamber as a group of like-minded people. Black people, like all individuals, are free thinkers, each with their own ideas. The idea people with similar skin tones all share the same "narrow viewpoints" sends us all back down the evolutionary ladder to a time when scientists believed mixing "black" blood with "white" blood was a death sentence. Fortunately, we now know, no matter what the outside of a person looks like, the blood inside is of one race - the human race. Imagine the lives that would continue to be lost if scientists held to the beliefs this article seems to advocate. I'm glad there is no name attached to this piece, as I have little to no respect for the author, whoever he or she may be, and have lost the same for this publication.
1. Our View: School board appointments: Status quo or no? DISPATCH EDITORIALS
2. Possumhaw: Finding daffodils in hard ground LOCAL COLUMNS
3. Slimantics: Mullen raises the bar of expectations LOCAL COLUMNS
4. Voice of the people: Debbie Wilkins Whitfield LETTERS TO THE EDITOR (VOICE@CDISPATCH.COM)
5. Froma Harrop: Open Internet survives weird politics NATIONAL COLUMNS