April 26, 2014 9:58:36 PM
JACKSON -- Attorneys for death row inmate Willie Jerome Manning are arguing again that Manning deserves a new trial for killing two sisters in 1993 in Starkville.
Manning is appealing an Oktibbeha County judge's denial of his post-conviction challenges related to evidence in his trial and his lawyer's performance.
In 1996, Manning was convicted and sentenced to death in the slayings of Emmoline Jimmerson, 90, and her daughter, Alberta Jordan, 60, during a robbery attempt at their Starkville apartment in 1993. The Mississippi Supreme Court upheld Manning's conviction and two death sentences in 2000.
But four years later, the high court granted Manning approval to pursue three post-conviction claims: that prosecutors withheld evidence; that they presented false evidence; and that Manning was denied effective counsel at trial and on appeal.
Circuit Judge Lee Howard ruled against Manning on all three issues in 2013. But Manning's attorneys appealed, claiming Howard's ruling denied Manning "an opportunity to develop a number of claims challenging the reliability of his conviction."
In a brief filed with the Mississippi Supreme Court on April 2, prosecutors argued Manning failed to prove he did not receive a fair trial. The Supreme Court gave Manning's lawyers until May 21 to reply.
During the initial trial, one of Manning's friends, Kevin Lucious, testified that he spoke to Manning at the Brooksville Gardens apartments on the evening of the killings and then saw Manning force his way into the women's apartment. Other witnesses also testified they saw Manning at the apartments. Manning denied he had been there.
Manning argued Lucious later recanted. Lucious said he was coerced by prosecutors into implicating Manning.
Special Assistant Attorney General Melanie Thomas said Lucious gave several statements to authorities about the slayings. She said it was only six years after the trial that Lucious argued he was coecered by prosecutors and the story changed each time Lucious was asked to describe how he was coerced.
"The only time his story ever made sense ... was when Lucious testified at Manning's trial," Thomas said in court documents.
Emily Maw, an attorney for the New Orleans-based Innocence Project, argued in a friend of the court brief that it was clear Lucious lied while testifying at Manning's trial. She said the very least the Supreme Court should do is reverse Manning's conviction so the case may be reinvestigated.
In May 2013, Manning had been set for lethal injection in a separate case -- the December 1992 slayings of Mississippi State University students Jon Steckler and Tiffany Miller. The state Supreme Court blocked the execution hours before it was scheduled. Justices didn't explain their action, but Manning had argued that DNA tests would prove him innocent. That case was sent back to Oktibbeha County.