The following related files and links are available.
July 15, 2009
Where''s Sallie Reneau when you need her?
Reneau was possibly the most persuasive woman Mississippian of her day. In 1856, at age 18, she convinced Mississippi''s governor and legislature to charter a state university for women -- never mind that such a thing had never been done before, in any state.
Now, Reneau''s own name is on a very short list of proposed new names for the Mississippi University for Women.
While Claudia Limbert, president of The W, won''t reveal her final choice for a new name for the college until Aug. 10, she did say that she will choose between two finalists -- Waverley and Reneau. The gender-neutral names are meant to broaden the school''s appeal to male students.
The university, whether intentional or not, hinted it might be tipping in favor of Reneau when it circulated in recent weeks a biographical sketch of the 19th-century educator, commissioned by the school and prepared by retired Ole Miss professor David Sansing.
The 16-page report outlines Reneau''s background and her efforts to start a state college for women.
Sansing also dispelled two misconceptions about Reneau -- that she or her family owned slaves, and that she attempted to organize a group of women to fight as soldiers for the Confederacy.
With the report, the university is seeking to make Reneau''s name more palatable to those opponents who say her image is insensitive to African Americans.
Of course, her name has many opponents who dislike it not because of racial connotations, but because it isn''t Mississippi University for Women. They are more vocal, and in the end will be tougher to appease.
Ahead of her time
Indeed, Sansing''s sketch reveals a woman who, if she were alive today, would still be ahead of her time in many ways.
Reneau was an 18-year-old recent graduate, embarking on a teaching career, when her plan to establish a state-funded teaching college reached the governor. Her letter so moved him that he endorsed her proposal, recommending the legislature enact it. This was at a time when there were no state-supported universities for women in the U.S.
I wonder how many times, before or since, a letter from an 18-year-old, male or female, had such an impact on a state leader.
And the legislature actually endorsed her proposal and chartered the school, to be built in Grenada where Reneau was teaching. But lawmakers didn''t fund it, and plans for the school eventually died -- overtaken by the more pressing matters of secession and a war against the North.
Reneau''s mother died in childbirth with her younger brother, shortly after the family moved to Mississippi from Tennessee. Sansing quotes records that show the family didn''t own slaves. Reneau''s father was a middle-class merchant, and was often away; she and her brother appeared to fend largely for themselves, living off and on with nearby relatives.
Reneau''s father and brother both fought for the Confederacy, and her brother died during the war.
In the months before the war began, Reneau, ever the organizer, again petitioned the governor, this time to form a group of "Mississippi Nightingales," who would "go around to the various camps ... to nurse the sick and wounded soldiers and to sew for those who might need it."
Essentially, Reneau was proposing the Red Cross, which wouldn''t be formed until years later.
The confusion comes in here: Reneau also proposed her group be issued pistols "to protect themselves in the lawless environment that parallels a state of war," and that they be issued uniforms.
And in an early blast of feminist thought, Reneau asked the governor to pay her group the same wage as he might pay a group of men.
In the end, the Nightingales weren''t funded, but Reneau still organized women in her own county to tend to soldiers in the field.
Sansing outlines how future historians would focus on her request for guns, pay and uniforms, and leave out the actual intent of the group.
Earlier attempts bore her name
After the war, Reneau again took up her effort to establish a state-supported women''s college.
And here is a good reason for MUW to be named for her: In a sense, it was named for her before. During the Reconstruction era, the legislature twice established the Reneau Female University of Mississippi, first placing it in Oxford, then Sardis. However, the school was never funded -- the same obstacle that blocked it before the war.
Reneau moved to back to Tennessee in the mid-1870s. During an outbreak of Yellow Fever in 1878, she organized a group to care for the sick. She, too, died of the disease, six years before another group of women including Annie Coleman Peyton and Olivia Valentine Hastings finally persuaded the legislature to fund a women''s university, this time in Columbus.
A shot in the arm
Today, MUW is the smallest Mississippi university; smaller than Mississippi Valley State; smaller than Alcorn State. Ole Miss'' medical center branch alone has nearly as many students as MUW.
While enrollment fluctuates up and down year to year, fall enrollment in 2008 was about the same as where it was in 1990.
Add to this a new challenge for the school that''s coming in just a few miles down the road. East Mississippi Community College is building a new nursing school, which will almost certainly funnel students away from MUW''s biggest program. The state College Board found there was a need for EMCC to have the program, over MUW''s objections.
Back in 1994, I was a reporter in Oxford, and covered the Ayers college desegregation trial, which had been sent back to federal court there from the Supreme Court for a retrial. The College Board''s solution at the time was to close and consolidate schools. As part of the plan, The W would be shuttered -- something that had been seriously considered since a funding crisis in colleges in the late ''80s.
With the economic downturn in full swing, a new state funding crisis is again upon us. I imagine talk of consolidation, whether serious or not, will come up again in coming years -- and MUW is still the smallest antelope in the herd.
MUW desperately needs a shot in the arm, and a smart public relations campaign surrounding a new name could help reinvigorate the school. It at least could put the school back on the radar for incoming freshmen -- a group that''s dwindling in numbers at The W.
While it''s up to the state College Board to say yea or nay on a new name, the final decision will rest with the Legislature. Opposition will be vocal. I fear legislators'' actions will be based more on politics than on the wishes of the College Board or of the university itself.
What will The W be called a year from now? Whether it''s Reneau, Waverley, or something else, some Sallie Reneau-level persuasiveness will be needed to make it happen, whether or not the school seeks to bear her name.
Steve Mullen is managing editor of The Dispatch. E-mail him at email@example.com.
Steve Mullen is Managing Editor of The Dispatch.
KJ commented at 7/16/2009 3:40:00 PM:
"I fear legislators' actions will be based more on politics than on the wishes of the College Board or of the university itself."
And what, exactly, isn't political about the College Board or the university itself? And does anyone expect a smart public relations campaign from either the College Board or the university? It's been one public relations fiasco after another for the current administration, including the current flap over the name. You would think that the "process" that produced these two names would have included the necessary research. Instead, we get the "research" (the quotes may be overkill, the research could be perfectly valid--but how smart is it to source it from a family member of the administration with a vested interest in defending the name change and the process by which a name is chosen?) as an afterthought, although a necessary one" meant to rescue the process.
What the W needs is a smart administration capable of delivering solutions rather than problems. I doubt, however, that the politics of the IHL Board will allow that.
Kim Kimbrough commented at 7/16/2009 4:43:00 PM:
Very nice reprint of a press release, Steve.
Question: Has the Commercial Dispatch done any research on its own to determine Reneau's past or thought of contacting an impartial historian to quote or confirm since there obviously is contradiction about her life? (You do realize than many people know Ole Miss Prof/Historian David Sansing is Perry's father, Perry being the Perry Sansing that is Assistant to the President and University Counsel for Mississippi University for Women.)
Since Peyton's and Hastings' efforts were the ones that actually got the school funded, it seems those are the names that should be considered over Reneau (if any should be considered at all).
And, you have got to be kidding if you think anyone believes this is an altruistic effort on the part of the current administration whereas the original disaffiliated alumni group (of which I am NOT an active member) is all about politics.(Steve, everything is about politics, yes everything.)
The current administration is now and has been engaged in politics from the moment Dr. Limbert changed her mind from her incoming statement that she could market the W with its current name. If you do not believe so, you are naive, which is a concern for someone at the helm of a fourth estate publication.
Too bad the Feds will not intervene as they did with GM and demand the captain who is sinking the boat be relieved of duties just as they did when they asked Rick Wagoner to skedattle.
Mississippian commented at 7/21/2009 7:09:00 AM:
Reneau still gives the "W" the appearance of being a womans college. I thought the main reason was to get away from being associated as a womans school. Just call it Columbus University or North Eastern.
Jim Spell commented at 7/28/2009 9:01:00 AM:
It appears Reneau was ahead of her times in Mississippi and certainly thought outside of the box. Her history certainly justifies her name being on the short list for the renaming of "that college in Columbus". For me the picture becomes clearer. Let's think of an entering student during the 2010-2011 school year. By then a decision will have been made, signs, letter head, business cards, etc have been changed to reflect the new name.
During registration for classes this students becomes aware of a required class titled "Reneau College History-From the beginning until Now". Well I'm sure some committee will come up with a better name but let's use it for now. Most students could care less about this "ole history" and, I suspect, as they discuss their college experience with relatives/friends the name "W" will come up often. The "W", wow, that is easier to remember and saves my brain cells for something more inportant and maybe related to my major. I think I will just remember that name. No wait, the new name is not Reneau-they call this place "Waverly". Great, another "W"; this will be an easy class for me.
The circle is now complete. Considerable time, energy, money has now been used to accomplish nothing of value to the education of students attending "that college in Columbus". But there will be a new required class for student to pay for. What a shameful use of resources. Folks should encourage the State Department of Education in Jackson to trash this whole plan.
1. Our View: Starkville aldermen pay raise is hard to justify DISPATCH EDITORIALS
2. Voice of the people: Mike Cooper LETTERS TO THE EDITOR (VOICE@CDISPATCH.COM)
3. Our View: Campaign finance needs more scrutiny DISPATCH EDITORIALS
4. Voice of the people: Cameron Triplett LETTERS TO THE EDITOR (VOICE@CDISPATCH.COM)
5. Leonard Pitts: Police brutality is a problem for everyone NATIONAL COLUMNS